Sunday, June 2, 2013

Ground 42: Pittodrie

Pittodrie
Game: Aberdeen 1 v 1 Heart of Midlothian
Date: Saturday 18th May
Competition: Scottish Premier League
Attendance: 10,465
Admission: £5
Programme: £3

This is it. The final game of the season. The 42nd ground of the year. You would have thought by this point I’d have learnt to take a jacket to a game. Even one in May. Instead I got wet. Really very wet. And damp. And miserable. All this before kick-off.

I’d booked my train up to Aberdeen as soon as the SPL split fixtures were confirmed, so I knew that my adventure would be finishing at Pittodrie. In a way, it was fitting as Aberdeen were the team I first supported as a four year old before, gasp, horror, I switched my allegiance to Hibernian.

I arrived in Aberdeen an hour before kick-off. By this point the torrential rain that had followed me on my journey all the way to the Granite City seemed to have dissipated. So I chanced my arm and decided to talk the 20 minutes from the train station to Aberdeen’s home ground. Big mistake. By the time I got to the ground I was absolutely drenched and my mood was made worse by checking my ticket to see I had a seat in Row D – right where the stand stopped being covered by the roof.

I thought I’d wait and see if all the seats in the covered section were occupied by kick-off and mercifully there were not and I was able to dive in a seat just as the game got underway.

The crowd of 10,465 meant that Pittodrie was only half-full, which was slightly disappointing given the much reduced admission for the dead rubber encounter but I imagine many people were put off by the weather. Completely understandable if I’m honest.

Yet there may not be a football ground near the city centre in Aberdeen for much longer. The club plan to move to a brand new stadium to the south of the city. It’s a move that I feel, could be disastrous for the club. There is no doubt that Pittodrie has seen better days, but when has a move to a new out-of-town stadium ever galvanised a club in Scotland? On the whole, they’ve become white elephants and the lack of transport links for the new Aberdeen stadium leaves me with a feeling this could be the same. Construction of the stadium has been delayed for a year, so perhaps common sense will prevail. What’s clear, however is that little money has been invested in the ground in the past twenty years – in fact, it looks the same as it did when I went to my first match here in 1994/5.

Pittodrie is dominated by a massive two-tier stand at the Beach End of the stadium, called the Richard Donald Stand. It towers above the rest of the ground, and makes it lopsided. The main stand is a typical construction and the South Stand where I was sitting is a large 8,400 embankment which in the east sections hosts away fans.

As I had mentioned, the weather was shocking. It was easily the worst playing conditions I’d seen all season – with puddles forming in parts of the pitch. It was clearly going to be a skiddy surface for the players.

The game didn’t really get off to a flyer and the most entertaining action in the early stages took place in the stands as a group of Dons fans unveiled a banner with the slogan: “Stewart Milne: epic fail”. Milne is the unpopular chairman of the underachieving Aberdeen and soon the fans right to protest was halted as the stewards moved in, removed the banner after a small confrontation and ejected one or two of the rowdier fans. The natives are clearly not happy.

And in all honesty, who can blame them? Aberdeen are an underachieving club. They are a one club team in Scotland’s third biggest city, which has been recession proof in these recent turbulent economic times. They are not a bottom six club, but have largely underachieved since the start of the 1990s. The shadow of Sir Alex Ferguson’s success in the 80s looms large over this club.

The news of the great man’s retirement was covered in Aberdeen’s excellent programme – certainly one of the best I’ve read this season, with lots of interesting content and lengthy pieces.

The game itself was what I was expecting from two underperforming clubs on the final day of the season. It wasn’t bad, but it hardly set the heather alight. Aberdeen had all the early chances and Hearts keeper Jamie Macdonald kept them in the game with several great saves in the first half.

Hearts, on the other hand could be summed up in one word: turgid. This was the third time I’d seen them in the flesh this season and they are not a pleasing outfit on the eye. Obviously matters have not been helped by off-the-field problems but for too long they’ve overpaid people to play football in an unattractive manner. By the amount of money they spend on personnel, Hearts should be finishing third every season in the SPL no problem, but that looks unlikely to be the case for the foreseeable future as belts get tightened around Tynecastle. Fortunately, they have a good few youngsters coming through, so hopefully footballing brains will replace brawn.

Despite Aberdeen’s penchant for 0-0 draws this season, I was impressed by how they were playing under new manager Derek McInnes. They passed a ball a lot better than I expected and one can only hope that will get better if the playing surface is allowed to repair itself over the summer, as certain games at Pittodrie this season have been notable for having more soil on display than grass!

However, what was disappointing about Aberdeen’s performance was that they still played it safe despite the outcome of the game not really mattering. It was rare for the midfield to push further up and support the attackers and even rarely for either of the fullbacks to support the players in front of them by overlapping or for those wingers to run at the shaky Hearts defence. Despite being denied a half dozen good chances by Macdonald in the Hearts goal, it was somewhat inevitable that Hearts were the team to take the lead. Having not looked in the game, Hearts pushed up and got a corner. From the set piece, Ryan Stevenson was able to wander free from his marker and head the ball home unchallenged.  A simpler goal you will not see for a very long time.

It would have been an injustice for Hearts to walk away with all three points and fifteen minutes after going behind, the Dons equalised after good work from Johnny Hayes saw Jamie Hamill put the ball in his own goal.

The rest of the game petered out, with both teams probably quite happy to not lose. It’s probably that sort of attitude that has them sitting 8th and 10th in the league respectively.

As the final whistle blew, it also signalled the end of my 42 Grounds adventure. I’ll be doing a few wrap up posts soon, so look out for that. One thing is for certain – I’ve thoroughly enjoyed (almost) every minute of it.

Saturday, June 1, 2013

Ground 41: Dens Park

Dens Park
Game: Dundee 2 v 3 Kilmarnock
Date: Saturday 11th May
Competition: Scottish Premier League
Attendance: 4,190
Admission: £20
Programme: £2.50


As I’m reaching the dog end of the season I was aware of the possibility that I’d be watching some games that would be dead rubbers. If the game at Dens Park was anything to go by, then I’m all for meaningless games.

I journeyed up to Dundee on the train with a hangover that was more brutal than a Siberian winter. Therefore, my decision to walk to Dens Park was a tad foolhardy, especially as the route took me up Hilltown, a rather steep hill.
Dens Park on the right, Tannadice in the distance on the left
This was only my second visit to Dens, the home of Dundee since 1899. The ground has two modern stands behind each goal. The Main Stand at Dens is unusual in Scottish football in that it is oval shaped, which isn’t too noticeable from inside the ground, but can be seen outside due to the shape of Sandeman Street. The stand on the opposite side is the Derry stand which runs for two thirds alongside the pitch. For my previous visit to Dens when Dundee played Aberdeen in the League Cup I know the Derry stand is where most of the atmosphere at Dens is created.

Dundee had been relegated the week before, so had nothing to play for but pride whilst Kilmarnock only had positional money to play for as the teams trotted out of the Dens Park tunnel and down onto the pitch. The weather was all over place (four seasons in one day) and I was heartened to see the home fans giving their team a warm welcome despite relegation. Truth be told, Dundee never had a chance of SPL survival as their arrival to the division was only confirmed a matter of weeks before the start of the season. This made it very difficult to get a squad capable of competing in Scotland’s top division.

The game was only four minutes gone when Kilmarnock took the lead through Rory McKenzie. McKenzie picked the ball up from ten yards inside his own half and ran with the ball. Dundee players backed off and eventually two of them tackled each other as McKenzie took the ball into box and stroked it home with his left peg. It was hard to describe a solo goal like that as nothing short of ridiculous. Evidentially, luck has not been kind to Dundee at all this season.

A visit to Dens is always aesthetically pleasing, and the home side have the classiest shirts in the SPL this season. What is not so pleasing is the clear bumps in the playing surface, which must have an impact of playing passing football. Another unpleasing aspect of the encounter was the performance of the referee (this looks like it’s becoming a theme doesn’t it?) who at no point looked like he had authority over the players on the park.

Dundee equalised in the 19th minute through Ryan Conroy’s close range effort after some good close passing from the boys in blue. Dundee had missed a good few chances preceding the equaliser as the Kilmarnock back four gave Dundee plenty of space, which has probably been the story of their season.

At half-time Dundee said goodbye to a club legend. Rab Douglas is departing the club after falling out with current manager John Brown and he received a touching standing ovation from the fans as he walked round all three sides of the ground occupied by Dundee fans. Even the biggest cynic could not have been touched by his kissing of the goalposts at the Bobby Cox Stand end.
Rab Douglas says goodbye
The second half continued in the vein of the first, with both sides attacking and trying to create chances. Kilmarnock took the lead for the second time in the 58th minute when midget left Chris Johnston cut inside from the wing, fired a shot at the edge of the box that was blocked and returned to him and the youngster blasted his second attempt into the faraway corner.

Johnston looks like a great prospect and I’ll be following his development as he’s a player that could get fans on their feet. Likewise Dundee’s Gary Harkins, a player who infuriates and delights in equal measure – he’s a lovely passer and a very skilful player but his work ethic is less than exemplary.

Kilmarnock doubled their lead seventeen minutes from time when Rabiu Ibrahim showed wonderful poise and balance to escape his marker and lay the ball into the path of Clingan, who curled a beautiful effort beyond Simonsen from 20 yards.

Mark Stewart pulled a goal back for Dundee in the 82nd minute with a neat lob of Cammy Bell but it wasn’t enough to get the Dee back in the game.

At full time the home fans were quite muted when their players were leaving the pitch, which was not surprising given relegation before the last home game of the season. There was glimmers of quality in this match, but not enough from Dundee to garner anything from the match. Which is probably the story of their season. If the club had got a proper pre-season in the knowledge they would be playing SPL football then no doubt they would have had a better tilt at staying in the division.